Looking for the best restaurants in Islamorada, FL? You have come to the right place!
Islamorada may not be where you think about first when you think of the Florida Keys but it was one the the best places we visited in the area due to the awesome activities and epic Islamorada beaches.
It also has some awesome Florida food to try in the restaurants in the area including traditional conch (pronounced konk) and Key Lime Pie (the best thing ever!). If you don’t feel like Floridian food, there is also lots of other restaurants to enjoy in the area including seafood, Italian, Caribbean, Japanese and traditional American which we have included in out list.
Whether you are on vacation, celebrating an anniversary or taking a weekend trip we’ve have put together this ultimate list of Top 30 restaurants to try Islamorada in 2022 with details including traveler ratings, cuisine and must try dishes.
See more: Things to do in Islamorada
30 Best Restaurants in Islamorada
#1 Bayside Gourmet 4.5 Ratings
- The Cuisine: Italian, American, pizza
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Brunch
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
Bayside Gourmet is the go to restaurant that has an “Anytime Menu” featuring soups, salads, gourmet specialties including Classic Cuban Press, Lasagnas, and A “Real Philly Cheesesteak”!
According to reviews the Philly is a must try because of its cheesy authenticity, paired with one of their rich and savory soups is a win-win. If you have room to try desserts take a look at the key lime pie and chocolate mousse pie.
#2 Mangrove Mike’s Cafe 4.5 Ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Cafe, Diner
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Dinner, Breakfast, Lunch, Brunch
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
Mangroves Mike’s Cafe is the best breakfast spot in town. It is definitely a hidden gem in the keys. The breakfast menu serves up delicious hotcakes & Belgian waffles in all sorts of yummy flavors (blueberry, strawberry, chocolate chip, banana nut, cinnamon apple) which all sounds so good!
They even have specials like Mangrove Mike’s Super Special that includes 2 hotcakes, 2 eggs, 2 slices of bacon or sausage for an affordable $8.99. The menu has a long list of items so it won’t be hard to find something delicious to try or eat.
#3 Square Grouper-Islamorada 4.5 Ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Bar, Seafood, Contemporary
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Spots, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Brunch
- The Atmosphere: Laid back waterfront operation with a deck
If you are a seafood lover this may be the spot for you. They have fresh local seafood, craft cocktails, and a great wine selection that has made this restaurant according to sources one of the most popular dining destinations in the Florida Keys.
Their dinner menu has a huge selection of featured starters like chicken wing lollipops which can be paired with buffalo w/house made blue cheese dressing or Thai sweet chili. If it was me dining here, I’d definitely try them with the Thai sweet chili. Their house specials range from square grouper seafood stew to Seafood platters (shrimp, fried conch, coconut shrimp, and local fish of the day).
#4 Wahoo’s Bar and Grill 4.0 Ratings
- The Cuisine: Seafood
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
Perched above the world-famous whale Harbor Marina, Wahoo’s Bar and Grill offers the Key’s freshest selection of locally caught fish and seafood which includes mahi-mahi, grouper, snapper, tuna stone crabs, and Florida lobster.
According to Miami Herald, they were voted as a restaurant with the 3rd best view. Whether you choose to dine in one of their two water-front decks or in the air conditioned dining room you get great food with a spectacular view of the crystal waters in the Atlantic Ocean.
#5 MEAT Eatery And Taproom 4.5 Ratings
- The Cuisine: American
- Special Diets: Gluten Free, Vegetarian or Vegan Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
This Restaurant has some of the best smoked meats in FL. Besides serving great meats, they have something for those wanting to keep things light like salads, fresh veggie dips and many more selections.
They have the #1 rated burger in Florida 2015-2017! The Inside out Juicy Lucy Burger is a must try, it’s top with pimento cheese a bacon stuffed 6oz. Angus burger topped with American cheese, lettuce and tomato. If this burger doesn’t convince you to stop in I don’t know what else will.
#6 Chef Michael’s 4.5 Ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Seafood, Vegetarian Friendly
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Dinner, Late Night
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
Whether you are celebrating an anniversary or going on a special date, Chef Michael’s might be that restaurant for you! Customers rave about the juicy steaks which are cooked to perfection and the plentiful fish and fresh seafood options available.
#7 Kaiyo Grill & Sushi Bar 4.5 ratings.
- The Cuisine: Japanese, Seafood, Sushi, Asian
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Dinner, Late Nights
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
This spot is Islamorada’s first Asian fusion and sushi restaurant. If you have late night craving for sushi like me this restaurant will be perfect since its the top Asian fusion spot in the area. Customer’s are always excited about their extensive options, exotic flavors and late night offerings.
#8 Ciao Hound 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: Italian, Tuscan, Central-Italian
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Breakfast, Dinner, Brunch
- The Atmosphere: Great laid-back and welcoming atmosphere
Fun and Family friendly classic Italian restaurant that is open for dinner daily. Many great vegetarian options and traditional classic Italian flavors.
#9 City Hall Cafe & Wine Bar 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Bar
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Drinks
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
This Restaurant has an extensive wine bar and beer selection, so if drinks are integral to your outing there’s plenty to choose from.
It is known as a family-friendly bar with exceptional service frequented by visitors and locals alike. If you decide to go don’t forget to pick up an award winning piece Key lime Pie as well!
#10 Ziggie & Mad Dog’s 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Seafood, Vegetarian
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Dinner, Late Night, Drinks
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
This restaurant is a casual, upscale type of place that is known for their steaks, chops and seafood. Need food and drinks late night? Reservations are recommended and you can easily reserve a table on their website for dinner.
#11 Islamorada Shrimp Shack 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Seafood
- Special Diets: Vegetarian friendly, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Brunch
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
It’s a family owned operated restaurant that serves all sorts of appetizers featuring shrimp. One of the most popular and local favorites is their famous shrimp fritters served with remoulade sauce. Other Shack favorites include fried zucchini sticks, fresh seafood baskets and much more.
#12 Lazy Days 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Caribbean, Bar, Seafood, Grill
- Special Diets: Vegetarian friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, Late Night
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
This is another award winning restaurant in Islamorada. Relax and enjoy oceanfront dining while sipping on one of their speciality drinks from Lazy Days (In Da Keys) which has Malibu Coconut Rum, Bacardi God, Pineapple orange and a splash of cranberry that will give you a nice sunny buzz!
They also serve plenty of appetizers like Fried Cracked Conch, Homemade Mozzarella Sticks, Potato Skins and many more!
#13 Green Turtle Inn Restaurant 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: American
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, Late Night
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
Green Turtle Inn has been an Islamorada landmark since 1947. There are many locally inspired seafood dishes including lobster mac n’ cheese, beer battered fish sliders topped with cilantro lime aioli and scallops with fettuccine. You cant go wrong if you’re looking for simple setting with good food!
#14 Pierre’s 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: Caucasian
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Dinner, Late Night
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
An elegant, romantic colonial-style restaurant on the beach offering seafood pasta’s of the day, herb garlic grilled flat iron steak and whole fried local fish.
Meals can be paired with a nice cocktail off the menu like the guest favorite Koke colada (keke key lime pie cream liqueur, bacardi lemon, pina colada mix, graham cracker crust).
# 15 Island Grill 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Caribbean, Bar, Seafood, International
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
Have you ever hear of tuna nachos? Me either until I found this spot! This island grill is located on the water for a nice view while dining. “Home of the original tuna nachos.”
They provide an all day sushi menu with their exclusive Islamorada roll, Overseas roll, California roll and many more. They also offer unique venues where you can host a large party or wedding within the restaurant. The gorgeous views and lively atmosphere brings a distinct and memorable vibe that customers come back for again and again.
#16 Nikai Sushi Bar & Restaurant 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: Japanese, Sushi, Asian, Seafood
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Dinner
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
Nikai Sushi Bar offers an array of tasty Japanese inspired cuisine using fresh ingredients, locally and internationally sourced fish, traditional spices and fresh vegetables to create a dining experience like no other. This stunning restaurant has a tropical setting with great service and many food options.
#17 Hog Heaven Sports Bar & Grill 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: Seafood, Barbeque, American, Pub
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Late Night, Drinks
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
If you want a fun spot to hang out or catch the latest football game with some great food and drinks this is the spot. This bar and grill is relaxed and open for you and your friends to hang out whether weekday or weekend!
They have grilled hamburgers, chicken wings, french fries, desserts and many other specials throughout the week.
#18 Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: America, Caribbean, Bar, Seafood
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, Late night, Drinks
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
Spacious bay front roadhouse with outdoor bar offering conch chowder, surf & turf and more. They also have a list of speciality entrees from Alaskan snow crab platters to vegan sauté’s which includes red skinned potatoes with zucchini, garlic, tomatoes, mushrooms, basil and onions.
#19 Habanos Oceanfront 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: Caribbean, Latin, Cuban
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
Cuban Restaurant that serves Cuban classic ranging from Cuban sandwiches to Cuban style pizza. They also offer other options as well like grilled chicken breast, skirt steak and many other options. If you are like me and loves Caribbean food with authentic flavor, this spot is a must try in Islamorada!
#20 Morada Bay 4.5 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Caribbean, Bar, Seafood
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Brunch, Late Night
- The Atmosphere: 5.0
Laid-back lifestyle of the Florida Keys and the beauty of Islamorada. If you want to dine on the beach with nice beautiful sunsets, I suggest you try this place. Especially great for couple’s who are celebrating a wedding anniversary or looking for nice atmosphere to relax and enjoy the views.
#21 Whale Harbor Seafood Feast ( Buffet) 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Seafood
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
Huge seafood buffet offering 85 items ranging from seasonal crabs, raw oysters, mussels, shrimp, fried yellowtail snapper, crab cakes, seafood rice, smoked salmon, fried shrimp, seafood chowder, conch chowder, bbq ribs, fried chicken, grilled vegetables, mash potatoes, pizza and all sorts of desserts like key lime pie, flan, cheesecake, chocolate cake many more.
Who doesn’t love a buffet of food with so many different options!
#22 Hungry Tarpon 4.0 Ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Bar, Seafood
- Specials Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Gluten Free options
- Meals: Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Brunch
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
They offer a large selection of specialty foods from breakfast to dinner. Want breakfast? The Cowboy includes 2 eggs any style served w /6oz. Steak or keep it simple with french toast & hash browns.
Lunch? Customers love the Wagyu beef sliders, 1/4lb beef hot dogs and fish platters. Enjoy your meal on their bayside deck lit by tiki torches with a nice beverage in hand!
#23 Marker 88 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Bar, Seafood
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
If you want a hangout spot to enjoy live music with family or friends while dining on the beach in the Florida keys this is your place!
People love their extensive cocktails and drinks from spicy watermelon margarita, 88 relaxer, and mai tai drinks. They also have a famous homemade key lime pie and variety of seafood options as well.
#24 Ocean View Inn & Sports Pub 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Bar
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Late Night, Drinks
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
Come here if you want to watch a game in their sports pub and outdoor restaurant. This is a hotel that have rooms with ocean views as well if you plan on staying the weekend or for one night in Islamorada.
#25 Islamorada Fish Company 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: America, Seafood
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
Owned by Bass Pro shops, this open spaced restaurant is situated under a tiki hut and serves up seafood with nice waterfront views. Try the local favorites, Islamorada fish and chips or the fried seafood shrimp combo basket.
#26 Tower of Pizza 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner, Late Night
- The Atmosphere: 3.5
Family owned since 1975, serving pizza, pasta & subs. If you need a quick bite to eat the varieties of pizza and Italian fare may be what you or your family need for a no fuss lunch or dinner.
#27 Atlantic’s Edge Restaurant 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: American
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
- Meals: Lunch, Brunch, Dinner, Drinks
- The Atmosphere: 4.5
Offers indoor and outdoor dining, overlooking the wonderful views of the Atlantic Ocean. If you are looking for breakfast, Atlantic Edge serves their famous lobster BLT omelet, NY strip huevos ranchero, and many other favorites daily. Be sure to check out their lunch and dinner menu.
#28 Meze Morada 5.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: Mediterranean
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options
- Meals: Lunch
- The Atmosphere: 4.0
Meze Morada serves made from scratch pita, delicious dips and spreads, fresh veggies, and grilled skewers. They also have desserts like ice cream & sorbet. Great place for vegetarian and vegan options.
#29 Puerto Vallarta 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: Bar, Seafood, Mexican
- Special Diets: Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner
- The Atmosphere: 3.5
If you enjoy Mexican food like fajita platters and homestyle dishes make sure to check this one out. It is family-owned serving authentic Mexican seafood in the Florida Keys.
#30 The Whistle Stop Bar & Grill and Wood Oven Pizza 4.0 ratings
- The Cuisine: American, Bar, Pizza, Pub
- Special Diets: Vegetarian
- Meals: Lunch, Dinner
- The Atmosphere: 3.0
Basic pub grub spot that has pool tables and TVs to watch sports on a Sunday night and enjoy a slice of pizza or grilled hamburger with French fries.
***
This sums up our awesome list of the top 30 best restaurants in Islamorada, FL right now in 2022. This list was hard to put together because there was so many great restaurant to choose from in the area offering different dining experiences.
****
More FL Keys fun:
- Best Campgrounds in the Florida Keys
- Bahia Honda State Park
- Things to do in New Smyrna beach
- Free things to do in Key West
- Best restaurants in Key Largo
