Looking for the best restaurants in Key Largo? You have come to the right place! There are seriously so many great places to eat in Key Largo, you are totally spoilt for choice.
The Florida Keys is a great vacation spot for everyone. The beaches offer infinite opportunities to swim, scuba dive, fish, and more. On land, there’s only plenty of fun stuff to do – like eat – one of our favorite past times. It’s really no surprise the Beach Boys loved it here.
The Florida Keys offer mostly a more casual dining experience so there not too much fine dining in key largo but that doesn’t mean the restaurants aren’t great.
After a day of swimming and exploring, here are 20 Key Largo restaurants for a tasty meal! Don’t wonder where to eat in Key Largo again with these top picks.
20 Best Restaurants in Key Largo
1. Florida Keys Bite
Located at 99000 Overseas Hwy, the restaurant is a favorite for vacationers, offering up some of the best food in Key Largo. Some of the big drawcards of this restaurant include the all-day service and hibachi bar.
Don’t miss the Keysbite Skillet for breakfast which includes Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Green Peppers, Tomatoes, Onions, Mushrooms, Spinach, Jalapeños or Sausage Gravy. Topped with American cheese and two eggs cooked to your liking, and toast. For $10.99 this presents excellent value in the Keys and is, therefore, a great restaurant to visit if you are traveling with kids and want a low-cost meal option.
There are also really great and affordable dinner options available like the Chicken Francaise (a Lightly battered chicken with white wine, butter and fresh lemon juice) which will set you back only $14.99.
As the Florida Keys is notoriously an expensive place to travel, Florida Keys Bite is a great place to go for an affordable but still quality meal in Key Largo.
2. Fish House
Featured on “Everyday with Rachel Ray,” “Good Morning America,” and “Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives,” among other publications and shows, The Fish House is a well-loved staple of the Key Largo area.
This place does a really mean sandwich so if you are a fan of a delicious sandwich we highly suggest you try Fish House. We would recommend the Mahi Mahi Sandwich Broiled & dusted with paprika, Grilled, Blackened, Fried or Jamaican jerk style. A sandwich at Fish House will set you back $15-$20.
Seafood is the big drawcard for dinner here which can be expected with a name like “Fish House”. If you are into blue cheese, you gotta come for dinner. Highly recommend the black and bleu topped with blue cheese crumbles and baked, then topped with a cream sauce of bleu cheese, garlic, blackening seasoning and white wine.
The Fish House has won three awards from People’s Choice Upper Keys, and Florida Living Magazine for the best key lime pie in Florida. Pop in at 102401 Overseas Hwy between 11:30 am-10 pm to try it yourself!
3. Hobo’s Cafe
Named by National Geographic as “one of the most authentic Keys eateries.”, Hobo’s Cafe has been loyally serving patrons since 1991 at 101691 Overseas Hwy.
This is another great place to enjoy Key Lime pie in Key Largo if you are looking for a good spot. If you haven’t already, we would recommend trying the Conch (pronounced Konk) fritters at this restaurant as they are really delish.
The restaurant also has t-shirts and hats for those who want a souvenir from the classic seafood shack. Check out Hobo’s Cafe for good, fresh food and warm service.
One of the best Key Largo restaurants for sure.
4. Num Thai and Sushi
For those who have had their fill of clams and shrimp, Num Thai offers delicious thai food including fried wontons, Thai red curry, and a spicy beef salad. You can customize their lunch entrees with chicken, beef, pork, or veggies.
The elegantly prepared dishes are a feast for all the senses, and the convenient carryout options mean you can enjoy them any time! At unit 3 or 103200 Overseas Hwy, enjoy a fresh take on cultural cuisine!
A great take out option to enjoy on the beaches of Key Largo.
5. Lazy Lobster
Lazy Lobster is the quintessential Keys seafood shack. With indoor and patio seating and live music every night, the party never has to end!
The lunch and dinner menus feature a range of lobster, pasta dishes, and sandwiches, along with a “hook and cook” option.
Chefs David Ornelas and Lupe Ledesma also have an in-house fish market so that you can bring the freshest seafood home for tomorrow’s dinner!
There are plenty of wine options to pair with your meal, from Kendall Jackson chardonnay to Oyster Bay sauvignon blanc. With over 700 reviews, Lazy Lobster has earned its four-star rating. Go down to 102770 Overseas Highway to check it out!
6. C&C Wood-Fired Eats
This Key Largo hot spot has the distinction of being the first to serve wood-fired pizzas in the area, and the wood-fire stove in the center of the restaurant is sure to grab attention and start a conversation.
In addition to pizzas, C&C is known for elegant charcuterie boards, originally opening as Cork and Curds at 99201 Overseas Hwy. The hip, sexy vibe makes this a perfect choice for date night.
If customers like a particular wine, they can buy a bottle or case for home, bringing sophistication back with them. For a fun night on the town, C&C is the place to be!
7. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen
Another favorite in the local awards, this restaurant has been run by sisters Paula and Angie since 1988. Their lunch chili is known as the best in the Keys, and they offer some pretty tasty hot dogs too.
If you find yourself looking for breakfast in Key Largo, don’t miss your chance to try the new”Mac” Attack which includes two Eggs, two bacon, two sausage links, two slices of French toast with homemade hashbrown casserole and sliced tomatoes.
One of the best places to eat in Key Largo.
8. Fernandez The Bull
For some Cuban flair, head to Fernandez the Bull! Latin tacos include pork, chicken, steak, and fish, while the Cuban sandwiches have various nuanced options for a full, flavorful experience.
Family-owned since 1985, Fernandez’s Naples location was awarded the best Cuban food in the city!! The spice-averse need not fear, but adventurous eaters can try the Fernandez Hot Sauce if they dare.
With live music Wednesday through Sunday, enjoy a night of cultural spice and delicious bites! The Key Largo location is unit 104 of the Tradewinds Plaza, at 101429 Overseas Hwy. There are two other locations in Naples, so there’s always some Cuban flair nearby!
9. Doc’s Diner
Another one of the best restaurants in Key Largo is Doc’s Diner, a favorite among locals. The restaurant placed first and second in various categories in the Upper Keys People’s Choice Awards, including Best Down Home Cooking.
The friendly staff serves the breakfast special of the day all day, and they even have a breakfast feast for five on their menu. Weekly lunch specials include Italian Tuesday and a variety of meat-veggie-potato combinations.
For some good old-fashioned home cooking, head on down to 99696 Overseas Hwy. If you go on Italian Tuesday, you might even get to meet Doc himself!
10. The Buzzard’s Roost – Best Key Largo Restaurants on the Water
The Buzzard’s Roost is an ideal port for the sailor, with their longitudinal and latitudinal coordinates listed in the directions and a “Hook and Cook” menu category.
Any cleaned and filleted fish brought in can be grilled, blackened, or prepared to the guest’s liking. For those who don’t want to hunt down their own meal, the dinner menu offers conch, yellow snapper, and other classic fish, along with plenty of salads, soups, and a wide range of lobster preparations.
The lunch menu also offers quesadillas and sandwiches, and weekend diners can catch Sunday brunch from 10:30 am – 2 pm. With a waterfront patio, a screened porch, and indoor dining, guests have options for enjoying the views, making it one of the best key largo restaurants on the water.
Visit The Buzzard’s Roost at 21 Garden Cove Drive for a truly authentic and immersive waterfront dining experience.
11. Arthur’s Island Kitchen
Arthur’s Island Kitchen is an excellent choice for eclectic Floribbean cuisine on a budget. If you love seriously good service, this is a great choice as they are well known in the area for treating customers like they are the only customers in the restaurant.
The classic bright walls and chalkboard menu bring the sunny atmosphere in from the beach. There’s something for everyone with unique options like callaloo soup and oxtail alongside classic sandwiches, steaks, and seafood.
The prices are pretty reasonable, and Arthur himself makes an effort to welcome guests. Sail on down to 102255 Overseas Highway for a twist on classic Florida fare.
12. Enrico’s Pizza
This is the place to get New York-style pizza in Florida! Located on Overseas Highway and also served at Jimmy Johnson’s Big Chill!, Enrico’s Pizza is a local favorite.
The family-owned business began in New York in the 1960s, and the legacy of authenticity carries on. Pizzas and calzones can be customized, or guests can choose from unique options like arugula, three-cheese without sauce, or eggplant pizza. The “pasta-bilities” are a blend of classics and unique seafood options.
For Yankees who want a taste of home, you can find it at 20 High Point Rd, in Tavernier. Enrico’s got your back.
13. City Hall Cafe and Wine Bar
City Hall is the perfect choice for sophisticated boaters, with delivery options, an extensive wine and beer service, and a “hook and cook” option (preparing cleaned catches that customers bring in).
The lunch menu offers sandwiches and burgers alongside classic seaside Florida fare. The dinner menu provides rich steak, veal, and seafood options, and the wine bar has plenty of pairing choices from Italy, California, and even New Zealand.
This is an excellent spot for a sophisticated dinner without breaking the bank. 88511 Overseas Hwy in Tavernier offers an elegant and modern night out for any palate!
14. Harriette’s Restaurant
This cozy breakfast joint offers a variety of staples, but they’re known for their giant muffins! From key lime to dulce de leche to bacon maple, Harriette’s homemade muffins are a must-taste for visitors and locals alike.
The cozy atmosphere lingers from before the family home became a restaurant. From the friendly faces to the warm and filling meals, Harriette’s feels like home, Stop in at 95710 Overseas Hwy for a cozy treat!
15. Pilot House Restaurant and Marina
Established in 1950, Pilot House has been a lighthouse to the city.
With live music three nights a week and visiting manatees on occasion, the long-standing hangout very popular with locals and tourists alike.The marina offers storage and fuel for the boats, while the restaurant and waterfront bar offer fuel for the sailors.
There’s a natural aquarium within the waterfront bar to keep the aquatic adventures and admiration afloat.
If you do visit this restaurant in Key Largo, we would recommend the Bahamian Conch Fritters with roasted red pepper and aioli, a great deal at only $12.75.
16. Jimmy Johnson’s Big Chill
Named after Super Bowl-winning coach Jimmy Johnson, this is the sports center of Key Largo.
With steaks, burgers, and even Enrico’s Pizza, there’s something for every palate. In addition to beers and wines, Jimmy’s offers a range of hard-hitting shots and cocktails.
10400 Overseas Hwy is a great spot to catch the game and have a few drinks with old friends. You might even see Jimmy Johnson himself on his Three Rings boat!
17. MEAT Eatery and Tap Rooms
This is the place to get a good burger in Key Largo. Many of their burgers and sandwiches, such as the Nancy Pants or pulled pork, have made local and national award lists such as USA Today, Travel+Leisure, and Good Morning America.
The awards are well-deserved for the in-house meats, sausages, and condiments!
MEAT also has unique menu options like duck-fat French fries and homemade Nutella ice cream for guests with a sweet tooth. For the best burger in the Keys (and the accolades to prove it), head to 88005 Overseas Hwy.
18. Señor Frijoles
For a classic fajita/margarita night, head to Senor Frijoles! The restaurant is best known for its range of tequilas and margaritas, backed by extensive knowledge.
Their happy hour specials include “toritos,” bacon-wrapped jalapenos for more adventurous eaters. In addition, the restaurant is close enough to the water to watch the sunset and the manatees playing in the surf. For a classic Mexican dinner with a fantastic view, head on down to Senor Frijoles.
19. Made 2 Order
As their tagline says, Made 2 Order might not be famous, but they are better. With an all-day breakfast and a wide variety of sandwiches and seafood for lunch, the menu has won over plenty of happy locals and visitors alike.
Their omelet options are endless and customizable. Everyone who goes there LOVES the berry pancakes, the Italian breakfast, the yellowtail, and pulled pork sandwiches, and the cozy and welcoming environment. For a small-town diner with plenty of options, head to 90691 Old Hwy in Tavernier.
20. Hide Tide
This newer restaurant offers a cozy spot for families, with breakfast from 6 am until 3 pm and a blend of American and seafood for lunch and dinner.
High Tide is an ideal spot for everyone to find something tasty. Specialty drinks like Bacardi Rum Punch, Tequila Sunrise, and Bloody Mary fit perfectly with any beach bash! High Tide cares about building a community; locals who want to stay connected can join the restaurant’s email list and enter to win prizes.
The service is always superb – servers may even share a seashell with special guests! For a cozy beach brunch, head to 99411 Overseas Hwy and join the family.