Looking for the Best Seafood Restaurants in Key Largo? You have come to the right place!
Key Largo is known as the scuba dive capital of the world, which makes it a popular destination for those seeking thrills and adventure. Key Largo has something for everyone, including a rich culinary scene.
When you visit Key Largo, you’d be remiss to miss out on their best seafood restaurants. Whether you’re looking for an amazing dining experience with a great view or the best lobster bisque in town, we’ve got you covered. Come on a culinary exploration with us as we map out the top best seafood restaurants in the beautiful Florida Keys.
15 Best Seafood Restaurants in Key Largo You Must Try!
Sundowners
Head on over to Sundowners for great food and a beautiful waterfront view. You can choose from outdoor seating and indoor sitting in their glass-walled dining room.
Either way, you’ll get to enjoy the expansive waterfront view which is especially impressive at sunset. Sundowners prides themselves on serving the freshest seafood in town and they’ve been doing so since 1985. Come enjoy their live music and extensive drink menu. They offer frozen drinks (mango daiquiri, piña colada), wines, specialty cocktails, beer, and more.
At Sundowners, you can start your meal off with one of their appetizers including coconut shrimp, conch fritters, hot crab & artichoke dip, and jalapeño poppers served with ranch dressing. They have something for everyone with their menu offerings of soups, salads, entrees, and sandwiches.
For their desserts, reviews are in that their key lime pie is amazing.You can also choose from oreo cheesecake, chocolate toffee mousse cake, and even a whole pie to-go.
Open every day of the week, be sure to put Sundowners on your list to try the next time you’re in Key Largo.
Address: 103900 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
See more: Best restaurants in Key Largo
The Fish House Restaurant & Seafood Market
The Fish House has been in business since 1982 and has received many awards through the years. The awards include best seafood restaurant, best key lime pie in Florida, best overall restaurant, and best service staff.
The Fish House welcomes its guests to come and try the amazing food and enjoy their laid-back atmosphere. If you want truly local and fresh fish, The Fish House is the place to go. They purchase their fish from local commercial fishermen.
Because they believe fresh is best, they fillet all their fish on-site before cooking and serving it to their guests. If you’re a foodie who loves fish and seafood, the menu at The Fish House will not disappoint. They have signature chowders including New England clam chowder and conch chowder.
For appetizers, try their crabmeat stuffed mushrooms, smoked fish dip, buffalo fried shrimp, and spicy tuna nachos. When you visit The Fish House, you’ll see Today’s Catch on their menu. The fish they offer daily can vary due to weather and supply since it’s all locally sourced. The Fish House is open for lunch and dinner, plus they have a seafood market.
Address: 102401 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Lazy Lobster Seafood Restaurant
At Lazy Lobster, Chef Lupe Ledesma and David Ornelas welcome their guests to dine inside or outside on the relaxed tropical-themed patio.
If you dine at night, you’ll enjoy your dinner alongside live music. Lazy Lobster is a friendly-family restaurant, offering menu options that will surely please the whole family. If you go fishing and catch your own meal, Chef Lupe will cook it for you. One of the best places for lobster in Key Largo.
Lazy Lobster has both a lunch and dinner menu. Here are some tasty options to choose from:
Lunch Menu:
- Lobster Mac and Cheese
- Fried Fisherman’s Platter
- Jalapeño Encrusted Ruben
- Steak Taco Salad
- Fried Lobster BLT Sandwich
Dinner Menu:
- Wasabi Encrusted Seared Tuna
- Lobster Key lime
- Chicken Piccata over Rice
- Pasta Frenzia
- North Atlantic Jumbo Scallops
Those are just a few options. The menu for Lazy Lobster is quite extensive so you’ll want to come back for more.
The kids menu at Lazy Lobster has options to please even picky eaters. On the menu, you’ll find options like mac’n’cheese, hotdogs, pasta, grilled cheese, chicken fingers, and fried shrimp. Bring the whole family and enjoy the scenery and cuisine at Lazy Lobster.
Address: 102770 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Snapper’s Oceanfront Restaurant & Bar
If you’re looking for great food and an amazing oceanfront view, Snapper’s Oceanfront Restaurant & Bar is the perfect choice. Snapper’s plays an important role in the history of Key Largo.
They’ve been serving locals fresh-caught seafood since 1989. The motto at Snapper’s is “Keep it Keysy.” Not only do they have a restaurant, but they also have four guest suites to choose from. You can stay on their property and try out all their menu options and Sunday brunch.
Be sure to check the calendar on their website to see who is signed up to play live music while you dine. Snapper’s has both indoor dining and dining outside on their expansive patio. Before or after you eat, you can try some water sports right from their oceanfront property.
They rent out a variety of gear including jet skis, paddleboards, snorkel gear, clear bottom kayaks, and more. On their menu, they have something for everyone including a kids menu. Some of the choices are seafood enchiladas, snapper’s shrimp burger, gator bites, house-made crab cake, and applewood-smoked bacon wrapped scallops.
Address: 139 Seaside Ave, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Key Largo Fisheries: Market, Cafe, Marina
Since 1972, Key Largo Fisheries has been supplying locals with fresh fish and seafood. Key Largo Fisheries prides itself on being an old-time fish market.
Fishermen pull their boats right up to the dock at Key Largo Fisheries and unload their catch. At their restaurant, they have both a relaxed breezy patio for dining and indoor seating. On the patio, you’ll enjoy live music and a waterfront view. Key Largo Fisheries promises the freshest Florida seafood prepped, cooked and delivered straight to your table. Their menu has over 100 items on it, including options kids will love.
For appetizers, choose from eat and peel shrimp, lobster bites, smoked fish dip, and conch salad. They have two hearty soups, clam chowder and lobster bisque. They also have salads, sandwiches, quesadillas, and tacos. Seafood lovers will enjoy their shrimp boat, fried conch boat, snapper boat, and conch boat.
These are platters of seafood served with fries. For dessert, you’ll have to try their mango cheesecake, key lime pie, and chocolate turtle lava cake. This family-friendly restaurant is perfect to add to your must-try list next time you’re in Key Largo.
Address: 1313 Ocean Bay Dr suite b, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
The Buzzard Roost
The Buzzard Roost offers waterside dining, a tiki bar, live music, and sunday brunch. Their outdoor seating is right on the garden cove marina.
They also have seating on their screened in porch or enjoy dining inside in their pine-paneled dining room. The Buzzard Roost offers hook & cook where you can catch your own fish and they’ll cook it for you. Enjoy a waterfront meal and choose from a long list of menu options.
The Buzzard Roost boasts that they offer the best steak, seafood, and homemade desserts. They have a drink menu and full-service bar. Their fish and seafood are local and fresh. The Buzzard is a family-friendly dining spot and offers a kids menu.
On Friday and Saturday nights, you can dine while listening to live music. If you’re staying in Key Largo for a while, be sure to try their Sunday brunch menu. With brunch, they offer the first mimosa complimentary to get you started off on the right track. Try their cornblue crab cakes, loaded potato skins, baked brie, fresh catch of the day, and more. For dessert, choose from their coconut cake, chocolate turtle pie, grand marnier crème brulée, and ice cream or milkshakes.
Address: 21 Garden Cove Dr, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Gilbert’s Resort Tiki Bar
Gilbert’s Resort is known for being the largest tiki bar in Key Largo, with live music, specialty drinks, and waterfront dining (with great seafood!). Both locals and tourists love the atmosphere and dining experience at Gilbert’s.
At Gilbert’s Resort, you can stay the night and try their restaurant. They have lodging at their hotel and boat storage for guests at their marina. Gilbert’s Resort has been in operation for well over 50 years in the beautiful Florida Keys, serving both locals and tourists.
The fun atmosphere at the tiki bar is enhanced with live music from both local and national musicians and bands. You can enjoy the largest tiki bar every day of the week and well into the night. They usually close around 11pm on weekdays but stay open until midnight on Fridays and the weekends.
Their fun speciality drink menu includes:
- Gilbert’s Punch
- Sippin Sangria
- Tiki mojito
- Spiked lemonade
- Gilbert’s spicy bloody mary
On their food menu, there’s a wide variety of options including a kids menu. You can choose from an assortment of seafood items and they also have menu options for meat lovers.
Cheeseburger, pulled pork sandwich and seafood options like conch chowder, grilled fish, conch & crab fritters and baked stuffed hogfish are just a few of the options on their menu. They also have a vegan burger for those wanting a non-meat option.
Address: 107900 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Pilot House Marina and Restaurant
If you’re looking for a fun and lively experience, Pilot House Marina and Restaurant is a top-notch choice for seafood or otherwise. Pilot House prides itself on being a local hangout since 1950.
As it states on their website, Pilot House is where the locals go to eat. The restaurant is right on Lake Largo so if you sit on the patio, you have a waterfront view while you eat. Manatees visit often so you might have visitors while you’re dining on the water.
Whether you’re in the mood for seafood dishes, prime rib, or want to try out their weekly specials, Pilot House has a menu that will please any foodie. You can eat outside on their covered patio, inside in their dining area, or directly at the bar. They have draft beer, cocktails, frozen drinks, and a variety of wines. Pilot House also offers gluten-free and vegetarian options for those with dietary needs.
They encourage their guests to inform them about any food allergies or dietary needs so they can cater to their guest’s specific needs. Their menu has something for everyone including a kids menu.
Some of their tasty menu options are pilot house baja style tacos, prime rib wrap, pan seared scallops, and shrimp pesto pasta. For dessert, try their warm apple crumble, fried key lime pie, warm brownie sundae, or sticky bun bread pudding.
Address: 13 Seagate Blvd, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Pilot House Restaurant and Marina/ Facebook
Alabama Jack’s
Alabama Jack’s is known for serving the best conch fritters in the keys. Locals and tourists flock to this restaurant for the waterfront relaxation and tasty menu options. Alabama Jack’s has been serving locals and tourists for over 50 years.
They are open 7 days a week and have live music on the weekends. Alabama Jack’s draws a diverse crowd of locals, families, bikers, tourists, and retirees. Locals refer to this relaxing dining spot as “Florida’s beach bar” and it’s rumored you might spot an alligator or two (from a safe distance).
You can dine outside with a waterfront view or indoors in their dining area. Besides trying their famous conch fritters, you might also want to dig into their fried fish sandwich, crab cake sandwich, and jalapeño poppers.
If you want to try a little bit of everything, they have a small and large seafood sampler platter. To end the meal, they have homemade desserts including key lime pie and chocolate peanut butter cheesecake. Alabama Jack’s is truly a traditional Key Largo experience for anyone wanting to dip their toes into the Florida way of life.
Address: 58000 Card Sound Rd, Key Largo, FL 33030, United States
Shipwrecks Bar & Grill
Shipwrecks Bar & Grill has a beachy atmosphere inside and out. They offer dining inside at their tables or directly at the bar. They also have outdoor seating on their covered patio with a waterfront view. Shipwrecks Bar & Grill is known as a laid-back dining spot that offers seafood dishes, comfort food, and beer on tap. Shipwreck’s is open 7 days a week, 11am-9pm each day. Their happy hour starts at 4pm and ends at 6pm.
Some of their menu options that sound amazing:
- Coconut onion rings served with thai sauce
- Homemade jalapeño poppers stuffed with crab & cheese
- Mahi mahi reuben
- Sauteed lobster
- Cajun shrimp pasta
- Orange tarragon stuffed fish
Shrimpwreck’s Bar & Grill also offers to cook your catch. They will cook the fish or lobster that you catch and bring in. This dining spot is great for individuals, groups, and families. They offer a kids menu with options that include grilled cheese, cheeseburger, spaghetti with garlic bread & marinara, and fried shrimp.
Address: 45 Garden Cove Dr, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Sharkey’s Sharkbite Grill
If you’re looking for a casual waterfront dining experience that’s open early until late, Sharkey’s Sharkbite Grill in Key Largo is a must-try. They are open 7 days a week, from 7am – midnight. If you happen to be staying in Bayside Inn Key Largo, be sure to mention it for a 10% discount on your meal.
Sharkey’s has been open since 2001 and has been a favorite of both locals and tourists. If you’re dining with your family and want a quiet spot to relax, you can enjoy your meal in their family style dining area which is on the second floor.
They also have a patio with a beautiful waterfront view which makes a great spot to catch the sunset. On the first floor of Sharkey’s, you’ll find their taphouse and pub. They have 32 beers on tap and a full liquor bar. This is a great dining experience if you want to socialize and watch local sports. Sharkey’s prides itself on being the best sports bar in Key Largo and offers its guests 20 televisions to watch their favorite sports and two outside patios.
A local favorite at Sharkey’s are the jumbo fish tacos. They have daily lunch and dinner specials that change daily.
Sharkey’s offers a friendly and casual atmosphere and encourages their guests to come in a t-shirt and flip-flops. Every night on the patio, you can enjoy the cool breeze and listen to live music provided by local musicians.
Sharkey’s happy hour is daily from 4pm-6pm and they specialize in microbrews and local small-batch beers that are sourced directly from the keys and Florida breweries.
Address: 522 Caribbean Dr, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Skipper’s Dockside
The atmosphere and offerings at Skipper’s Dockside are perfect for relaxing, watching sports, and enjoying the beautiful sunshine in Key Largo. Skipper’s is conveniently located at Mile Marker 100 and its tropical oasis vibes encourage guests to slow down and enjoy life.
On the menu, you’ll find some of Florida’s freshest seafood and Skipper’s Dockside’s signature cocktails. You can enjoy your meal inside in the spacious dining room or outside on the lengthy patio.
hey also have an outside tiki bar where you can try their specialty drinks and enjoy a waterfront view. Skipper’s is open Monday through Thursday from 12pm to 9pm and Friday through Sunday from 12pm to 10pm.
You can start on with some appetizers or soup and then dive into their hearty entrees and dessert. For appetizers, they offer options like dockside nachos, angus beef sliders, crispy calamari, and enchilada shrimp. They have gluten-free menu options on the menu as well and they are labeled GF.
For a main dish, try their fish of the day, key largo platter, or the jerk bbq roasted chicken with sweet plantains. They have so many tasty options that you’ll want to keep coming back to try more.
Address: 528 Caribbean Dr, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Sal Ballyhoo’s Restaurant
If you’re in Key Largo and looking for fresh Florida seafood with a southern twist, Sal Ballyhoo’s is the perfect place to try. This local favorite has won many awards including traveler’s choice of 2020.
At Sal Ballyhoo’s, they pride themselves on serving amazing food alongside true southern hospitality. They’ve been doing so in the Florida Keys for more than 30 years. You can sit inside in their dining area or at the counter on traditional diner stools. They also have outdoor patio seating.
Sal’s has a dedicated vegan and vegetarian menu with a variety of options including appetizers, entrees, salads, sides, and housemade desserts. Some dishes can be made gluten-free. But if you’re looking for seafood with a southern flare, try the New Orleans BBQ shrimp, gumbo, ballyhoo’s fish & fried tomato sandwich, and the bourbon pecan pie. They also offer “you hook it, we cook it.” A good cheap option for seafood in the Keys.
Bring your own cleaned catch and they’ll make it into a meal for you. Choose from their southern inspired sides like the sauteed green beans with bacon salt, and tossed to order coleslaw. At Sally’s Ballyhoo’s Restaurant, you’ll find southern charm and food that will comfort your soul.
Address: 97860 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
Blackwater Siren
Blackwater Siren is a rustic and casual dining spot that looks like a tiki bar. It’s a great place to kick back, enjoy some great seafood and relax while dining on their waterfront patio. The view is gorgeous, especially at sunset. Blackwater Siren is a fun dining spot frequented by locals, and you’ll love the laid-back Florida Key’s vibe.
They are open every day of the week starting at 11:30am and stay open until 9pm each day except Friday and Saturday when they stay open until 10pm. Blackwater Siren has something for everybody and offers gluten-free and vegetarian menu options.
Some of their appetizer options:
- Spicy shrimp gazpacho
- Coconut onion rings
- Buffalo shrimp
- Basket of fries (seasoned waffle fries, sweet potato fries and steak fries)
For entrees, seafood lovers will enjoy the sauteed seafood pasta, blackened mahi tacos, and tomato bacon shrimp. They have homemade desserts including key lime pie, ultimate chocolate cake, peanut butter pie, and cheesecake. Be sure to add Blackwater Siren to your must-try list for a relaxing waterfront dining experience.
Address: 107690 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
The Catch Restaurant & Bar
The Catch Restaurant & Bar welcomes its guests to enjoy local seafood and a family-friendly atmosphere. They offer food and drink specials that change daily. The Catch welcomes guests with dietary needs and offers to find something for everyone on their menu.
The Catch is perfect for those needing vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. Since 2013, The Catch has been serving locals and tourists fresh local seafood and homemade dishes. They have a bar that features drink specials that change daily and their signature cocktails. Come try their happy hour specials, served Monday through Friday.
The Catch has breezy outdoor seating and cozy indoor seating, with a chalkboard that changes daily and showcases their catch of the day and specials. Their appetizer menu won’t disappoint and features options like shrimp bruschetta, cayenne shrimp, spinach artichoke dip, and stuffed mushrooms.
If you are in the mood for a sandwich, they have a variety of options including black bean veggie burger, baked mahi sandwich, and philly cheesesteak. On their dinner menu you’ll find must-try dishes like their coconut encrusted mahi, key lime chicken, and vegetable primavera.
Address: 102041 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States
***
See more:
- Best seafood restaurants in Destin FL
- Ultimate Guide to Sailing the Florida Keys
- Best Beachfront hotels in Key Largo
