Skip to Content

10 Best Sanibel and Captiva Island Beaches

Looking for the very best Sanibel island beaches?

Heading up the West Coast of Florida you will find he most divine beaches of the likes of Marco Island, Naples beaches and Bonita Springs.

We thought we had seen in all in terms of Florida beaches but as we drove over the Sanibel Causeway we realised Sanibel Island Beaches were different – not only were they situated in a lush, tropical paradise but they had waves, something we had not seen before along Florida’s west coast!For sure one of the best beach towns in Florida

One of the biggest drawcards to Sanibel and Captiva island is that these beaches are considered some of the very best shelling beaches in Florida!

6 Best Sanibel Island Beaches

Sanibel Island is a very popular island off the coast of Fort Myers in Florida.

To achieve tropical beach paradise, you need to cross over Sanibel Causeway bridge to Sanibel Island.

The bridge to Sanibel Island from Fort Myers costs $6 USD but it is very worthwhile if you are looking for great beaches – Sanibel Island beaches are gorgeous.

We loved that Sanibel Island had a very different look and feel to it than Fort Myers. As you enter the island you drive into lush, tropical paradise. Green is literally everywhere!

In fact, you can’t actually see the houses as you drive along the roads as the view is restricted by palm trees and other green vegetation (much different to Naples Beaches where mansions line the streets).

The island looks like how I imagine Hawaii to be – wild and Jurassic park like – although I have never been to Hawaii, someone will have to tell me if this vision is accurate.

Sanibel Island has a very chilled and relaxed vibe. Many of the residents choose not to drive cars but to cruise around the island on bikes.

Summary: It is a very cool place with great beaches – totally worth checking out if you are headed to Fort Myers.

1. Causeway Park & Beaches

The first beach that you will approach as you drive into Sanibel Island is Causeway Beach Park.

It is not the best beach on Sanibel island but it is the cheapest Sanibel Island public beach. It is one of the only places on the island that you can park for free.

Most other beaches on the island cost $5 USD per hour to park. Yes, you heard me right. $5! It is indeed very expensive but the beaches are lovely so it is a worthwhile expense.

The great thing about this beach is you can park virtually on the beach. It is a great spot to have a picnic or go for a quick dip.

There are facilities at the beach including restrooms, BBQs and picnic tables.

Don’t spend your entire time at this spot as our favourite beaches in the area are coming up soon.

2. Blind Pass Beach: Sanibel Shelling

Far up the other end of Sanibel Island you will find Blind Pass Beach.

Shelling is a very popular pastime in Florida (there is also great shelling in Marco Island for example).

If you are interested in picking up some lovely shells at the beach, Blind Pass Beach is the place to head in Sanibel island. It is known as being the best shelling beach on Sanibel Island.

Another activity that is popular on Blind Pass Beach is fishing. You can catch a wide range of fish from catfish, to bonnet head sharks at Blind Pass Beach.

The beach is NOT the best for those who wish to swim. In fact, signs actually warn against swimming at Blind Pass Beach due to the currents. If you wish to swim, it is best to pick elsewhere!

For this reason and the fact there are no toilets or showers available, we wouldn’t recommend the beach to families.

3. Sanibel Lighthouse Beach Park & Fishing Pier

This was one of our favourite beaches in Sanibel Island due to the cute little lighthouse at the beach. If you are looking for the best Sanibel Island public Beach, this is quite possibly it.

Sanibel Lighthouse Beach is a great place for photography on Sanibel Island. If you want to take fabulous pictures of the beaches in Sanibel Island, this is the best Sanibel Island beach for it!

Nearby the lighthouse is a beautiful beach with some nature trails. We spotted some great picnic tables at Lighthouse Beach Park if you are looking for a good spot.

Like the rest of the island, it costs $5 an hour to park at Lighthouse beach.

There are plenty of facilities available at the beach including restrooms, showers, picnic tables and BBQs.

sanibel-beaches-lighthouse-beach

4. Gulfside City Park Beach

Right next door to Lighthouse Beach is our personal favourite beach in Sanibel Island – Gulfside City Park Beach.

In our opinion, this beach had the best surf, the best sand, the most beautiful ocean and it was the most interesting!

On the day we visited there were many people kite surfing which made for a very enjoyable afternoon looking out at the sea. You could seriously be entertained for hours looking at the kite surfers at the beach!

You can easily walk or bike to Lighthouse Beach from Gulfside Beach.

It costs $5 per hour to park (no surprise here) but there are good facilities including restrooms, showers, picnic tables and BBQs.

sanibel-beaches-Gulfside-City-Park-Beach

5. Bowman’s Beach

Bowman’s Beach is located at the far end of the island near Blind Pass Beach.

It is thought of as the sunset beach. It has the best sunsets in Sanibel Island so make your way there late afternoon to enjoy a stunning orange sunset.

Bowman’s Beach is a bit more of a mission to access than the other beaches on Sanibel Island – from the parking lot to the beach is a 10 minute walk so it may not be suitable for elderly or young children.

The beach does boast good facilities including toilets, showers and BBQ grills.

6. Tarpon Beach

In the middle of Sanibel Island you will find Tarpon Beach, one of the best Sanibel Beaches.
 
At Tarpon Beach you cannot park direct at the beach itself. There is a parking lot just down the road from the beach entrance. Fortunately, unlike Bowman’s Beach it is a fairly short walk from the parking lot.
 
This beach was very pretty, fairly isolated and had tonne of wildflowers growing at the time we visited which were really pretty.
 
There are toilets and showers available at this Sanibel beach.
 
sanibel-beaches-Tarpon-Beach

Best Captiva Island Beaches

If you keep driving right to the end of Sanibel Island, you will approach Captiva Island. Sadly, there is not a great deal of public beach access on Captiva Island as it is lined with beautiful homes and hotels.

For those planning a special vacation South Seas Island resort has fabulous beach access.

Obviously, this private resort is not open to the general public so if you are looking for a freely accessible public beach in Captiva Island, these are the two main Captiva Island beaches open to the public – Turner Beach & Captiva Beach.

Turner Beach

On the Captiva side of Blind Pass Beach you will find Turner Beach, a fabulous Captiva public beach. You will actually find this beach both on Sanibel and Captiva Island.

It is the first beach after you leave Sanibel Island.

Like Blind Pass Beach, Turner Beach is best for shelling and fishing, but not swimming as the currents can get very strong! There are also great sunsets at Turner Beach if you find yourself there later in the day!

There are restrooms and showers available at Turner Beach but not on Blind Pass Beach on the Sanibel Island side.

It costs $5 per hour to park.

best-captiva-island-beaches

Image credit: Flickr

Captiva Beach

If you have made it all this way – congratulations you will be rewarded with some of the most beautiful sunsets on the island. If you are looking for great Captiva island beaches – this has to be one if not the best beach on Captiva island!

If you would like to enjoy this beach for a while longer and make a proper weekend of it, we recommend staying at the South Seas Island resort as it is just nearby this beach.

Captiva Beach has less facilities than the Sanibel Island beaches – there are no restrooms and limited parking.

On the plus side if you like isolated beaches, this may be the beach for you!

It costs $5 for 2 hours to park.

Before you leave, consider popping into the Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum which is devoted to every aspect of seashells, conchology, and malacology, including the paleontological and archeological/anthropological aspects of the study of shells (which means there’s some pretty old shells in there).

Image credit: Flickr

More beaches:

  • Bonita Beach Park (a Bonita Springs beach)
  • Alison Hagerup Beach Park (14790 Captiva Drive, Captiva Florida)

Where to stay near Sanibel beach? Sanibel Island Hotels

If we had our chance again, we would recommend staying directly on Sanibel Island not making day trips from Fort Myers.

Here are where we would suggest staying in Sanibel Island. In our opinion, these are the best hotels in Sanibel Island:

sanibel-island-hotels

Image credit: booking.com

Sanibel & Captiva Island Tips/Information

After visiting Sanibel Island, here are our best tips for the island paradise:

  • Bike not Drive. Car parking is very expensive. Bike parking is free. Get my drift? Once you enter the island you can rent at bike at Finnimore’s Cycle Shop or many others on the island.
  • If you are on a budget bring some snacks with you from the mainland. Like Key West, it is more expensive on Sanibel Island.
  • Despite food & parking being fairly expensive, petrol isn’t too bad so don’t stress if you don’t fill up in advance.
  • You are allowed to take home shells from the beach as long as there is not a living creature inside.
  • Most beaches will not allow you to enjoy alcoholic beverages at the beach
  • No open fires are allowed at the beaches
  • Sanibel Island public Beach parking generally costs $5 per hour. It is not worthwhile to risk it as the fines are $75+ for no ticket.

If you have a family, take your kids on the Sanibel Thriller Boat Ride to see dolphins!

***

More Florida fun: